Home > Eco-Friendly > Hand-Cranked Items > Natural Peanut Butter Mixer
Natural Peanut Butter Mixer
View Larger Image

Natural Peanut Butter Mixer

Item #
38 reviews
Today's Price: $9.95
This item has options!
Quantity: 
The oil in non-hydrogenated peanut butter naturally separates over time, but Grandpa Witmer's Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Mixer stirs the oil back into the peanut butter.
  • Prevents an oily mess
  • Easy to use
  • Molded plastic knob
  • Small is designed to fit a 16 oz. jar with a 3"OD diameter lid.
  • Large fits 26-oz jars with 3-1/4"OD lids.
  • Does not fit all jars, please measure lid diameter before purchasing!
  • Made in USA
Note: Large mixer lid comes in plain white.

AMERICAN-MADE STORIES:
Click here to read more about this mixer and the creator behind it.

Natural Peanut Butter Mixer

The oil in non-hydrogenated peanut butter naturally separates over time, but Grandpa Witmer's Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Mixer stirs the oil back into the peanut butter. <ul> <li>Prevents an oily mess </li> <li>Easy to use </li> <li>Molded plastic knob </li> <li>Small is designed to fit a 16 oz. jar with a 3"OD diameter lid. </li> <li>Large fits 26-oz jars with 3-1/4"OD lids. </li> <li>Does not fit all jars, please measure lid diameter before purchasing! </li> <li>Made in USA </li> </ul> <em><strong>Note: </strong>Large mixer lid comes in plain white. </em><strong><br /> <br /> AMERICAN-MADE STORIES: </strong><a target="_blank" href="http://countrylife.lehmans.com/stirring-up-change-right-here-in-amish-country/">Click here to read more about this mixer and the creator behind it.</a> peanut butter stirrer, stirer, stirring, mixing, stirrer, stirer, stirrrer,Smucker's stirrer,natural peanut butter stirrer,USA,US,made in US,Made in USA,USA-made,USA made,Made in America,American made,American-made,America
This item has options!
Quantity: 
NATURAL PEANUT BUTTER MIXER DESCRIPTION
The popularity of all natural, non-hydrogenated peanut butter is growing as people discover its genuinely nutty flavor and healthy benefits. However, the peanut oil often separates and collects in the top of the jar, potentially causing an oily mess.

Not to worry! Grandpa Witmer's Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Mixer easily stirs the yummy ingredients back together for smooth spreading.

To Use:
  1. Replace the lid on your peanut butter jar with the mixer lid
  2. Place the stirrer down into the jar
  3. Turn the handle for perfectly blended peanut butter

Customer Reviews of Natural Peanut Butter Mixer
Product Rating: 4.4 out of 5.0(38 reviews)
Showing comments 1-10 of 38 (Next 10)
- 9/24/2013
said: BostonJenn
"Lots of folks have made great comments, but I wanted to add one detail -- If you store your unopened peanut butter upside down, so that the oil settles in the bottom of the jar, this works perfectly. If you do that, when you open the jar all the liquid is on the bottom, and it mixes up just fine, even if the stirrer may not quite reach the bottom of the jar for some peanut butter brands (it does on one of the two brands we buy). One more hint: Cleaning up is less messy if you pull out the handle and stirrer from the lid BEFORE unscrewing the lid from the jar. The rubber gasket scrapes it thoroughly clean on the way out, so it does not drag out peanut butter or drip on things when removed."
Was this comment helpful? yes no (20 people found this comment helpful, 0 did not)

- 4/27/2013
said: Anonymous User
"With peanut butter, the mixer doesn't reach the bottom, the thickest layer. After using the mixer, I have to use a table knife to reach, loosen, and stir in the solids at the bottom. This takes almost as much work as just doing the whole job with the table knife, which is how I've always done this. Using the mixer -- mixing, disassembling, washing, and reassembling -- takes about as much work as manual stirring. So using the mixer, then using a table knife to stir in the bottom layer, is about twice the work of just mixing manually. The mixer works well with almond butter, which doesn't separate as strongly as peanut butter. But again, with all the cleaning involved, it doesn't save any effort or time. This mixer is a nice idea, and I hope someone improves the design. But after using mine several times, I gave it away."
Was this comment helpful? yes no (10 people found this comment helpful, 0 did not)

- 8/30/2012
said: Jeanne
"I like the concept and overall it mixes adequately, but the rubber seal around the lid deteriorated and got gooey and into the peanut butter. I'm not sure what caused the rubber to break down - I hand washed it so it wasn't exposed to very high water temperatures. All this said, I'm ordering a replacement because my husband likes this mixer better than using a knife."
Was this comment helpful? yes no (10 people found this comment helpful, 0 did not)

- 9/6/2013
said: David
"I didn't try it on Lehman's PB but the lid didn't fit either of the other two jars of the brands I buy. I usually get Adams PB. I am back to stirring it in the mixer."
Was this comment helpful? yes no (8 people found this comment helpful, 1 did not)

- 12/10/2010
said: Heather
"We picked this item up on our last trip to Lehman's. We were thrilled with it at first. After awhile the bubber ring around the mixer deteriorates and gets in the peanut butter and no longer wipes the mixer clean when you remove it. Great idea needs some work."
Was this comment helpful? yes no (8 people found this comment helpful, 0 did not)

- 6/21/2014
said: Jill Worsley
"Great idea - liked comment on how to adapt when lid does not quite fit. For those having problems with it reaching the bottom of the jar try what I have done using the knife method. Pour off some of the top oil and save in a small jar. Stir top half and add saved oil when you reach the harder dry part. If you have oil left over use for cooking or salad dressings."
Was this comment helpful? yes no (7 people found this comment helpful, 1 did not)

- 3/30/2012
said: Joanna
"This mixer DOES mix the peanut butter and it DOES keep the mess to a minimum. It DOES NOT mix it completely. When I saw this and read the reviews I thought the design would work much like a dough hook in an electric mixer - wrong. There is a 'dead space' in the center that requires mixing up with a knife. I had the peanut butter at room temp, but had to leave it and come back over several hours to get it pretty well mixed, then do a final mixing with a knife. I will keep mine since it is such a big pain to start it off mixing with a knife, but the design - I believe - could be improved."
Was this comment helpful? yes no (7 people found this comment helpful, 0 did not)

- 5/13/2014
said: Geoff Delp
"EXCELLENT product! Just got it and followed directions on back; works perfectly! Laid jar on side and turned handle over counter edge; mixed beautifully. Clean-up a snap; no peanut butter left on stirred when pulled out. Might have to get the big one, now!! :-)"
Was this comment helpful? yes no (6 people found this comment helpful, 0 did not)

- 11/21/2013
said: Michele Benedict
"This lid did not fit any of the 4 different brands I tried with it. These are not obscure brands. I tried to operate it with a loose fit and got peanut butter all over me, the jar, the counter top. Well, you get the picture. Very unsatisfactory. Waste of money and not worth returning."
Was this comment helpful? yes no (6 people found this comment helpful, 0 did not)

- 11/18/2013
said: Diana
"I love this product!! After years of slowly stirring with a messy knife, this has been a wonderful improvement. I especially like how the stirrer comes cleanly out of the lid...a peanut butter squeegee! No messy dish washing. I recently ordered a new one but only because a kitchen "helper" threw away a part not knowing how vital it was. Otherwise everything is still working great after many years."
Was this comment helpful? yes no (6 people found this comment helpful, 1 did not)

Showing comments 1-10 of 38 (Next) Click Here to see all comments