Feb 25, 2017
I had a piece of ShooFly Pie when I was a kid, and didn't like it. For some reason, however, I decided to give it another chance: different baker, different source, different me? Oh yes! I kept mine in the freezer to dole out small slices at a time. Didn't work. It was gone within days. Sent some to friends and relatives out of state - same thing there. Plain (nothing really plain about this pie) with tea or coffee, or topped with whipped cream or ice cream, it's a keeper!
Dec 26, 2016
I had never had Shoo Fly Pie and ordered it because of the old song and curiosity. The pie arrived fresh and delicious. Everybody in the family loved it. I highly recommend it.
Love the shoofly pie
Nov 20, 2016
I'm hooked. I have ordered a number of the shoofly pies. I now share with our oldest son and number three grandson. We have ordered a number of them, shipped from Bird in the Hand Bakery in PA. Their shipping is great. Arrive in perfect condition. Thanks Lehman's for a outstanding product.
Dec 18, 2013
Oh my! Better than I remembered from many years ago when I lived in PA! Every bite is worth the price :)
Dec 3, 2013
horrible. never get it!
Dec 18, 2009
Absolutely worth every penny ! Not as sweet as the description makes it out to be but the pie crust is to die for.
Oct 23, 2009
The shoe fly pie tastes just like the shoe fly pies my Grandma and Mom used to make. It is very sweet, we serve it with vanilla ice cream and coffee or hot tea.