Hand-Picked Products
Hand-Picked Products
Reviews
Disappointed
Mar 10, 2022
It's beautiful. And heavy. Which is why we were so surprised and disappointed that on our third or fourth use, it significantly warped while in the oven. Worse than any other baking sheet we've had. Then it did not flatten completely when it had cooled down. Also unlike any other baking sheet we've had. So, cancel the plans to order more.
Lehman's says: We are so sorry to hear of the warping! Reach out to us so that we can hear more from you and make things right!
OK
Feb 5, 2022
I bought two of these, only used one so far. They are heavy, however, the one I've used did warp and it wasn't put in a 450 degree oven either.
Lehman's says: We're so sorry to hear this happened! Please reach out to us at 1-800-438-5346 so we can make this right.
Nice looking but poor performing
Dec 24, 2021
I was initially pleased at the appearance and weight of this baking sheet, but the first time I put it in the oven it warped. It did not warp and spring back after cooling, it appears to be permanents warped. I'm very disappointed, as I had been looking for stainless steel baking sheets and would have bought more.
Lehman's says: We are very sorry that this product did not meet your expectations! Reach out to us so that we can chat with you and make it right!
Warping
Dec 18, 2021
I agree in part with the other reviews. They don't stick, they are mirror finished, they are kinda heavy, they Brown evenly. These are only used for baking mainly cookies. The problem they warp every time we have used them. They return to normal shape after they cool down just kinda irritating. Sometimes cookies are lopsided.
Sheets
Nov 8, 2021
I regret my purchase. I bought two of these sheets recently. After using them at normal oven temperature of 350 F both sheets warped and would not stay flat anymore. I feel that I waisted my money and regret that I have not bought USA Pan heavy duty sheets instead.
Lehman's says: Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We are sorry to hear that you experienced this with your baking sheets. We have multiple options for our customers that can be viewed both in store and on our website! Please reach out to us so that we can help you find the cooking sheet that best fits your needs!
The Best Cookie Sheets Ever
Feb 26, 2021
I've had my cookie sheets for several months now and I use them all the time for more than baking cookies and biscuits. These cookie sheets are really nice and top quality. They clean up well and I haven't had any issues with cleaning off anything. They are solid and heavy so they don't warp. I have found some foods cook and brown more evenly in these cookie sheets than any other cookie sheet or pan I've ever used in the past. That was a surprise to me. I've never had biscuits to bake and brown more evenly before I baked them on these cookie sheets. If you want a quality cookie sheet, these are the ones for you, they're great!
cookie sheets
Sep 17, 2020
We just received our cookie sheets and they are super nice. I was surprised how heavy they are!!!! My husband said you could use them for a mirror when you weren't baking with them!!! :) I baked with one yesterday and the food hardly stuck to the pan and the small cleanup was so easy. As always and true to Lehman's style....quality is top notch.
Lehman's says: We're so glad you are happy with your purchase!
